The Three Stooges Of Zamfara Govt: When Governance Becomes A Political Theatre

When the pursuit of personal relevance and political influence begins to overshadow institutional responsibility, governance risks becoming a theater of comedy.

There is something remarkably familiar about the political drama unfolding within the corridors of power in Zamfara State. It bears an uncanny resemblance to the legendary American comedy series, The Three Stooges, featuring Moe Howard, Larry Fine and Curly Howard.

The Three Stooges became famous for their extraordinary ability to turn simple assignments into complicated disasters. Their comedy revolved around competing egos, poor coordination, misplaced priorities, personal disagreements and an almost pathological inability to work together. What should have been straightforward frequently degenerated into confusion and comic absurdity.

Unfortunately, the metaphor raises uncomfortable questions about the dynamics of power and institutional relationships within the Zamfara State Government, particularly concerning the Secretary to the State Government, Abubakar Nakwada; the Chief of Staff, Mukhtar Lugga; and the Deputy Governor, Malam Mani Mummuni.

One is compelled to ask: Are these three critical offices functioning as complementary institutions in service of the Governor and the people of Zamfara State, or has the business of governance become entangled in competing political interests, personality differences and the struggle for relevance?

MOE: THE POLITICS OF CONTROL AND THE ILLUSION OF AUTHORITY

In the Three Stooges comedy, Moe was the dominant personality and short-tempered. He always want to control everybody, dictate the direction of events and maintain unquestionable authority over his colleagues.

In the political theatre of Zamfara, the Secretary to the State Government occupies an office of considerable institutional significance. The SSG is traditionally expected to serve as the administrative nerve centre of government, coordinating government business, facilitating policy implementation and ensuring effective communication across Ministries, Departments and Agencies.

It is an office that demands maturity, administrative discipline, political restraint and institutional integrity.

However, the office becomes problematic when administrative authority is perceived to be an instrument for personal influence, political dominance or the advancement of private interests.

The real test of an SSG is not how many people he can command, how much political influence he can accumulate or how close he can position himself to the Governor. It is how effectively he facilitates governance and translates government policies into tangible outcomes.

The office should be a coordinating institution, not a personal empire.

LARRY: THE POLITICS OF ACCESS AND THE CORRIDORS OF POWER

Larry - Tall and lanky was the character who frequently found himself caught between Moe’s aggression and Curly’s eccentricities. He was often an intermediary in an environment where coordination was almost nonexistent.

The Chief of Staff, Mukhtar Lugga, occupies a particularly sensitive position within the political architecture of Zamfara State Government.

The Chief of Staff is expected to manage the Governor’s immediate administrative and political environment, facilitate executive engagements, coordinate access and ensure that the Governor’s priorities receive appropriate attention.

It is a position that requires exceptional discretion, loyalty to institutional objectives, political intelligence and an understanding of the distinction between personal access and public authority.

The danger arises when access to the Governor becomes confused with ownership of government.

A Chief of Staff must understand that the office is not a political franchise, neither is it a private investment designed to generate personal influence or material rewards.

The office should facilitate governance, not become a gatekeeping mechanism for patronage, political favouritism or the distribution of privileges.

The question is whether the office is being deployed primarily to strengthen institutional coordination or whether the politics of access and influence have become more important than the business of government.

CURLY: THE COMEDY OF INSTITUTIONAL DISPLACEMENT

Curly was arguably the most entertaining of the Three Stooges. Tagged for his inability to speak English. His unpredictable behavior and seemingly endless capacity to turn ordinary situations into extraordinary confusion made him unforgettable.

The Deputy Governor, Malam Mani Mummuni, occupies an office that should command considerable constitutional and political respect.

The Deputy Governor is not merely an appendage of the Governor. The office has constitutional significance, responsibilities and an important place in the executive structure of the state.

The Deputy Governor should be a dependable partner in governance, providing leadership, supporting policy implementation and contributing meaningfully to the administration’s development agenda.

Consequently, any situation in which the Deputy Governor appears institutionally marginalised, politically diminished or reduced to ceremonial relevance raises legitimate questions about the functionality of the executive structure.

The Deputy Governor should neither be a spectator in government nor a participant in unnecessary political theatrics.

The office deserves dignity, responsibility and meaningful institutional engagement.

THE GET-RICH-QUICK SYNDROME: WHEN PUBLIC OFFICE BECOMES A PRIVATE OPPORTUNITY

Perhaps the most disturbing dimension of political leadership in Zamfara State is the increasing attraction of public office as an avenue for rapid personal enrichment.

The get-rich-quick syndrome has become one of the most damaging tendencies threatening public administration and democratic accountability.

Public service, which should ordinarily represent a commitment to collective welfare, is sometimes perceived as an opportunity to accumulate wealth, establish patronage networks, acquire influence and secure material advantages within a relatively short period.

This mentality is fundamentally incompatible with the ethics of public service.

A political appointment is not an investment opportunity. Public authority is not a personal asset. Government contracts are not instruments of private enrichment, and access to public resources does not confer ownership over them.

Where allegations of unexplained wealth, favouritism, procurement irregularities or conflicts of interest arise, the appropriate response should be transparency, independent scrutiny and accountability. No public official should be above examination.

The question is not whether an individual has become wealthy. The question is whether the sources of such wealth are legitimate, transparent and consistent with the responsibilities of public office.

Zamfara State deserves public officials whose ambition is measured by the quality of their contributions to society, not by the speed at which they accumulate personal fortunes.

THREE OFFICES, ONE GOVERNMENT: WHERE IS THE COORDINATION?

The Secretary to the State Government, the Chief of Staff and the Deputy Governor occupy different but complementary positions in the executive architecture. Their responsibilities should reinforce one another.

The SSG should facilitate government-wide administrative coordination. The Chief of Staff should ensure effective executive management and facilitate the Governor’s priorities. The Deputy Governor should provide constitutional and political leadership while contributing to the administration’s development objectives.

There should be no competition over who is more powerful, who enjoys greater access to the Governor or who exercises greater political influence. Government is not a contest for personal supremacy.

When these offices become centres of competing interests, the consequences extend beyond the individuals involved. Ministries and agencies may become confused about reporting relationships, government business may suffer delays, political appointees may become divided into competing camps, and public policy may lose coherence. Ultimately, the ordinary citizen pays the price.

Zamfara is not short of challenges requiring the urgent attention of its political leadership. Insecurity, poverty, unemployment, infrastructural deficits, weak institutional capacity and the need for economic transformation demand a coordinated and disciplined executive team. The State cannot afford a government whose internal political calculations consume more energy than its development agenda.

The SSG must coordinate, not dominate.

The Chief of Staff must facilitate.

The Deputy Governor must participate meaningfully, not merely occupy an office.

These are not personal privileges. They are institutional responsibilities entrusted to individuals on behalf of the people.

CONCLUSION: ZAMFARA IS NOT A COMEDY STAGE

The Three Stooges entertained millions of people because their failures were fictional, their conflicts were scripted and their mistakes were deliberately exaggerated for comic effect.

Governance, unfortunately, is not entertainment.

The consequences of administrative confusion, institutional rivalry, misplaced priorities and the misuse of public authority are real. They affect public finances, security, economic opportunities, social development and the future of generations yet unborn.

The people of Zamfara entrusted their future to a leadership expected to deliver security, development, accountability and responsible governance.

The three offices under discussion must therefore rise above the politics of ego, access, patronage and personal advantage.

If there are allegations of corrupt tendencies, abuse of privilege or the pursuit of personal enrichment, they should be subjected to credible scrutiny rather than dismissed as political gossip. Public office must remain a public trust.

And perhaps the most important lesson from the Three Stooges is that when people entrusted with different responsibilities spend more time nursing ambition and scheming rather than working towards a common objective, the result is almost invariably chaos.

Zamfara needs statesmen, not political entertainers; institutional builders, not empire builders; and public servants, not private entrepreneurs operating under the cover of public office.

And the Governor must decide whether he wants a team that will build Zamfara or a cast of characters whose political theatrics may eventually become the administration’s most memorable legacy.

Written by An Independent Mystery Shopper